Now, more than ever, with the new and improved Facebook Pages, it's important to make sure that you've don't confuse a profile and a page. Each has unique advantages over the other for particular purposes.
You can control what your friends see on your profile, whereas all fans have 100% access to page content. You can use friend lists to control access to individual aspects of your profile. For example, you may prefer to keep vacation photos hidden from a "client" list, and restrict people you don't know well from reading certain status updates and personal information. It's impossible to control who sees what content on a fan page.
Profiles are reciprocal, whereas Page admins can't see the Walls of their fans (likers) unless they are also friends. With a personal profile, you can read content on your friends' walls and interact there if your friends' privacy controls allow it. With pages, you have one space to intereact, on your page wall. You don't have the option to initiate a dialog on your fans' walls.
Profiles have friend limits, whereas pages are unlimited. Friends cap off at 5,000, so if you have a popular brand, you will have to insult all the extras by not friending them. You have the potential for millions of page fans, however.
Friends are mutually approved, whereas fans just simply like your page. Imagine the workload of manually accepting the 29M+ fans on the Lady Gaga page! On the other hand, it's nice to make an individual determination about each friend request and place each friend into an appropriate list at the point of connection, for privacy purposes
Pages can see usage statistics, whereas profiles have no statistics available. Since profiles are for personal use, there's really no need other than curiosity satisfaction for profiles to have stats available to them. Pages, on the other hand are for businesses, non-profits, entities, causes, products, etc. Admins have a vested interest in tracking who is coming to their page because the page is an investment intended to produce some result.
Once your friend leaves the buisness, who is managing that "company" profile and accessing your personal info? This one is a little scary when you think about it. You might accept a friend request from a "company" profile because you know the person who created it, for example, if your friend heads up the sales department. But what happens when your friend no longer manages that profile? Who now has access to your personal information on your own profile? Will you even know when/if a transition occurs?
Pages display videos prominently, whereas profiles bury them under photos. Video is one of the most significant marketing tactics available these days, and the latest generation of Facebook profiles not only got rid of the ability to highlight them in your left margin, but they also lumped them under your photos link in your left nav. Thankfully, Facebook retained the videos link in the left nav of the new pages, so they retain their prominence as a marketing tool.
Pages are accessible web-wide, whereas profiles can only be viewed by Facebook members. If you're looking for maximum exposure for your business, why would you want to hide your Facebook presence from people who aren't logged into Facebook?
Profiles allow elaborate messaging, whereas you can only announce an event via pages. Facebook's messages enhancements made it possible for you to now see a comprehensive trail of all private communications between you and a Facebook friend, including chat. It also allows you to add friends and remove yourself from a thread. On the other hand, pages have extremely limited private communications capabilities.
Profiles and pages have distinct advantages and disadvantages depending upon your intent. Basically, if you're looking to market a business, product, cause, band, public figure, or non-profit, a page is the way to go.
- Christine Pilch